
He spent nearly two weeks in federal custody and was eventually moved to a facility in Texas. His case rallied his school, Haitian advocates and California lawmakers.
On Tuesday, Nov. 17, a banner outside Fay Elementary School in City Heights welcomed back one of its third-graders. It was for an 8-year-old Haitian boy who had been reunited with his family the day before, after nearly two weeks in federal custody. He returned to class that day. A San Diego Unified School District spokesperson said he met with administrators and counselors so he and his family get the support they need.
What happened
On Nov. 4, the boy had a routine immigration check-in at ICE’s office in downtown San Diego. He had lived with his uncle since his father was deported to Mexico last year. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) said the uncle could not prove legal guardianship. The agency took the child under the William Wilberforce Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act of 2008, an anti-trafficking law, and transferred him to the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR).
A volunteer observer filmed three armed federal agents walking the boy into an elevator. The video spread, sparking outrage and protests at the federal building.
A family left in the dark
When he was taken, neither the family nor the boy’s attorney knew where he was or how to reach him. “It’s part of the problem with the system,” attorney Andres Moreno II told KPBS. He said ORR speaks only with verified family members, which delays the moment a lawyer can talk to the client.
The uncle had a signed, notarized letter from the boy’s father naming him as the boy’s guardian. Moreno said that is usually not enough; officials look for formal guardianship papers or a power of attorney. Still, he argued ICE could have let the uncle go home for other proof of family ties, such as birth records, instead of taking the child.
The boy was eventually moved to an ORR facility in Texas; Moreno does not know which one. ORR also has a facility in Los Angeles. Moreno said he does not know why the boy was not sent there, possibly for lack of space, but that moving a child that far from family is unusual.
The pressure that brought him home
San Diego’s Democratic congressional delegation, led by Rep. Juan Vargas, joined both California senators in a letter to the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) demanding his release. KPBS reported that Vargas worked his connections in the Trump administration until he found a sympathetic ear: a father of young children who, Vargas said, told him, “I’ll try to do something.”
The Haitian Bridge Alliance worked to bring him back to his family. On Monday, Nov. 16, the boy was reunited with his family; a photo published by KPBS shows him with his uncle outside San Diego International Airport. Moreno said cases like this can take 30 to 60 days to resolve. KPBS credits congressional and public pressure for his release.
The government’s side
ICE said that because it could not confirm the uncle’s guardianship, it removed the child from the household as a precaution and placed him in ORR care. DHS said the boy was returned once the uncle established guardianship. DHS also alleged that the boy was originally brought into the country illegally with a man who claimed to be his father; KPBS reports that the family entered the U.S. legally in 2019. HHS, which oversees ORR, said family reunification is the goal for every child.
What comes next
The boy had Temporary Protected Status (TPS) for Haitians, which the Trump administration ended this year. The school district tied the case directly to that decision. In a letter to the DHS and HHS secretaries, it condemned family separation and warned that the trauma did not end with his return. The district is providing crisis counseling and support for students and staff.
If you or someone in your family has an upcoming immigration check-in, or questions about guardianship of a child, contact Moreno & Associates. Call (760) 631-5330 for our Vista office or (619) 422-4885 for our Chula Vista office.